Self-hosted

Home Assistant: Raspberry Pi or mini PC

The question is not “what runs it today” but “what will you add in a year”.

5 min read
Home Assistant czy Raspberry Pi

Everybody asks which hardware to put Home Assistant on, and almost everybody asks it in the wrong tense. The honest version of the question is not "what will run it today" — nearly anything will. It is "what will I want to add to it in a year, and will this thing still be enough then".

What the Pi does genuinely well

A Raspberry Pi running lights, sensors and a handful of automations is not a compromise. It is silent, it draws a few watts, it costs little and it will sit on a shelf doing exactly that job for years. If your house is lights, heating, a couple of door sensors and some schedules, the Pi is not the budget option — it is the correct option, and anybody telling you otherwise is selling something.

Where it runs out

Three walls, and they arrive in a predictable order. The first is the memory card. Home Assistant writes to its database constantly, and flash cards wear out from writing. People discover this when the house stops responding one morning and the card turns out to be read-only. It is avoidable — boot from an SSD instead — but it is the single most common way these setups die.

The second is memory, and it arrives the moment you add something that indexes. A photo library building thumbnails, or a camera system deciding whether the thing in the driveway is a person, are not the same kind of workload as switching a lamp. They are hungry, and they are hungry continuously rather than in bursts.

The third is video. Cameras produce a stream that somebody has to decode, and doing that on a general-purpose processor burns it entirely. Ordinary desktop processors have dedicated silicon for exactly this job, and it is the difference between a machine that is busy and a machine that is on fire.

What an ordinary computer gives you instead

Memory measured in tens of gigabytes rather than units. Room for normal SATA drives, which matters enormously once there are recordings to keep, because recordings are not small and they do not stop arriving. Hardware video decoding. And a build quality that was designed for a machine left switched on in an office for five years, which is precisely the duty cycle of a home server.

The cost is electricity. A desktop machine draws more than a Pi — not dramatically more at idle, but measurably, and over a year it shows up on a bill. That is the real trade, and it is worth stating plainly rather than hiding behind benchmarks.

How to choose once instead of twice

The rule I use is a single question: will there ever be a camera or a photo library in this house. If the answer is no and you are confident about it, buy the Pi, boot it from an SSD rather than a card, and stop thinking about hardware. If the answer is yes, or "probably, eventually", then buying the Pi first means buying twice, because the second purchase is not an upgrade — it is a different machine and a migration.

There is a middle path that often gets overlooked: a used business desktop costs roughly what a well-equipped Pi costs, because the second-hand market prices offices clearing out hardware that still has years in it. You are not paying a premium for the headroom. You are paying for somebody else's depreciation.

Prefer not to build it yourself?

oftionn home box is exactly this: Home Assistant, AdGuard and Music Assistant configured on a refurbished business-class Dell, tested, with a 12-month warranty. From 799 zł. There is a live demo — log in and press whatever you like before you decide.